Amherst, NY · 25 sq ft
Public Storage 5x5 prices in Amherst
The 5x5 is the steadiest unit in Amherst. Its 88% spread across 8 branches is the narrowest of any size in this market, so $65 is close to what you should expect anywhere, with the cheapest branch at $52.
The cheapest of the 8, at $52 in Getzville, rates 4.8 over 432 reviews — none of the others is rated higher, so the low price here is not the trade-off it often is.
The further half of the 8 runs 13% below the closer half, out by Lancaster, though the $52 unit in Getzville is not the furthest of them.
$52
$0$98
All 8 branches, cheapest in Getzville
| Location | Area | Units listed | Cheapest online | Range at this branch | Regular rate | Rating & reviews |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2750 Millersport Hwy | Getzville 14068 | 3 | $52 | $52–$70 | $78 | 4.8 |
| 3953 Walden Ave | Lancaster 14086 | 3 | $54 | $54–$65 | $80 | 4.8 |
| 4871 Transit Road | Williamsville 14221 | 1 | $64 | — | $96 | 4.8 |
| 2733 William Street | Cheektowaga 14227 | 1 | $66 | — | $100 | 4.6 |
| 3420 Niagara Falls Blvd | North Tonawanda 14120 | 1 | $70 | — | $104 | 4.8 |
| 105 Hospitality Centre Way | Tonawanda 14150 | 1 | $74 | — | $112 | 4.7 |
| 2855 Niagara Falls Blvd | Amherst 14228 | 1 | $76 | — | $114 | 4.8 |
| 3671 Sheridan Drive | Amherst 14226 | 1 | $98 | — | $146 | 4.8 |
Where these numbers come from. 8 advertised prices read from Public
Storage's own published listings across 8 locations, last checked
2026-08-27.
Online rate vs regular rate. Every listing publishes two figures. Measured across thousands of observations, the regular rate is 1.5× the online rate at the median, with 88% inside 1% of that and none outside 1.40–1.60×. That is a pricing rule, not a second quote. The online rate is the promotional price for booking on the web; the regular rate is what the unit reverts to. Budget on the regular rate. Comparisons here hold the basis constant, so the gap between locations is real either way.
These are advertised rates for new rentals, not quotes — Public Storage states prices are not guaranteed and they move with availability. Insurance, admin fees and limited-time offers are not included.
How this is measured. The sampling, the percentile method and the rules for withholding a figure are set out on the methodology page. The figures are published as CC BY 4.0 and may be reused with attribution.
Cite this. Storage Price Index (2026). Public Storage 5x5 storage unit prices in Amherst, NY. Read 2026-08-27. CC BY 4.0. https://storagepriceindex.com/storage/amherst-ny/5x5/
Online rate vs regular rate. Every listing publishes two figures. Measured across thousands of observations, the regular rate is 1.5× the online rate at the median, with 88% inside 1% of that and none outside 1.40–1.60×. That is a pricing rule, not a second quote. The online rate is the promotional price for booking on the web; the regular rate is what the unit reverts to. Budget on the regular rate. Comparisons here hold the basis constant, so the gap between locations is real either way.
These are advertised rates for new rentals, not quotes — Public Storage states prices are not guaranteed and they move with availability. Insurance, admin fees and limited-time offers are not included.
How this is measured. The sampling, the percentile method and the rules for withholding a figure are set out on the methodology page. The figures are published as CC BY 4.0 and may be reused with attribution.
Cite this. Storage Price Index (2026). Public Storage 5x5 storage unit prices in Amherst, NY. Read 2026-08-27. CC BY 4.0. https://storagepriceindex.com/storage/amherst-ny/5x5/