Storage Price Index

Price data

Storage unit prices in New York

Nowhere we measure costs more than New York. Its median 10×10 is $184, 96% over the national figure, and the 7 markets inside it run from Amherst at $122 to Brooklyn at $234.

Brooklyn — $234 median 10x10 across 34 locationsPatchogue — $156 median 10x10 across 22 locationsAmherst — $122 median 10x10 across 9 locationsBethpage — $174 median 10x10 across 5 locationsRochester — $160 median 10x10 across 4 locationsNew Windsor — $131 median 10x10 across 3 locationsSpring Valley — $159 median 10x10 across 3 locations BrooklynPatchogueAmherst
$122 to $234 median 10×10 dot size = locations

7 New York markets, Amherst the cheapest

Markets in New York by median 10x10
MarketLocations Median 10×10vs New York
Amherst 9 $122 -34%
New Windsor 3 $131 -29%
Patchogue 22 $156 -15%
Spring Valley 3 $159 -14%
Rochester 4 $160 -13%
Bethpage 5 $174 -5%
Brooklyn 34 $234 +27%

New York by size

Unit sizes available in New York, by coverage
Size Sq ft Locations Cheapest Median Dearest Per sq ft vs US
5x5 25 81 $28 $64 $200 $2.56 +88%
5x10 50 84 $21 $106 $298 $2.12 +96%
5x15 75 58 $53 $161 $366 $2.15 +115%
10x10 100 83 $42 $182 $498 $1.82 +94%
10x15 150 80 $64 $234 $701 $1.56 +98%
10x20 200 72 $94 $278 $887 $1.39 +87%
10x25 250 26 $131 $295 $582 $1.18 +79%
10x30 300 41 $89 $314 $911 $1.05 +51%

Inside New York

  • The dearest market in New York is also its largest: Brooklyn, 34 locations at a median of $234.
  • Branch and city weigh about equally in New York, 90% against 92%.
  • Cheapest of the 7 New York markets: Amherst at $122, then New Windsor and Patchogue. Dearest: Brooklyn at $234, after Rochester and Bethpage.
  • Amherst, the cheapest, is a cluster rather than a city limit. It takes in Cheektowaga, Getzville and Lancaster.
  • Brooklyn, the dearest, takes in Bronx, Long Island City and Staten Island.
Where these numbers come from. 638 advertised prices read from Public Storage's own published listings across 80 locations in 7 markets, last checked 2026-08-31.

Online rate vs regular rate. Every listing publishes two figures and the regular rate is 1.5× the online rate at the median. That is a pricing rule, not a second quote. Figures here are the online rate (the promotional price for booking on the web) unless labelled otherwise. Budget on the regular rate.

Advertised rates for new rentals, not quotes; they move with availability. Insurance, admin fees and limited-time offers are excluded. This covers Public Storage only, which is a limit of what is collected here rather than of what exists. Not affiliated with Public Storage.

Cite this. Storage Price Index (2026). Storage unit prices in New York. Read 2026-08-31. CC BY 4.0. https://storagepriceindex.com/states/ny/