Brooklyn, NY · 25 sq ft
Public Storage 5x5 prices in Brooklyn
Nothing in Brooklyn swings like the 5x5. 253% across 35 branches, $38 to $134. It is the size worth shopping hardest here, and a typical one goes for $78.
Driving out pays here: the outer half of the branches runs 26% cheaper than the inner half, and the $38 unit in Bronx is about 7 miles from the middle of them, with the furthest 20 miles out in Staten Island.
$38
$0$134
All 35 branches, cheapest in Bronx
| Location | Area | Units listed | Cheapest online | Range at this branch | Regular rate | Rating & reviews |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 367 Southern Blvd | Bronx 10454 | 8 | $38 | $38–$69 | $58 | 4.7 |
| 2636 Arthur Kill Rd | Staten Island 10309 | 2 | $39 | $39–$49 | $59 | 4.9 |
| 275 Veterans Road W | Staten Island 10309 | 3 | $40 | $40–$46 | $60 | 4.7 |
| 1223 E New York Ave | Brooklyn 11212 | 7 | $49 | $49–$57 | $73 | 4.6 |
| 1055 Stewart Ave | Garden City 11530 | 2 | $58 | $58–$93 | $86 | 4.9 |
| 817 Peninsula Blvd | Hempstead 11550 | 3 | $64 | $64–$84 | $96 | 4.8 |
| 60 E Kingsbridge Road | Mount Vernon 10550 | 2 | $66 | $66–$66 | $98 | 4.7 |
| 1107 Goethals Road North | Staten Island 10303 | 2 | $67 | $67–$67 | $101 | 4.7 |
| 479 5th Ave | New Rochelle 10801 | 2 | $67 | $67–$83 | $101 | 4.8 |
| 4055 Austin Blvd | Island Park 11558 | 1 | $67 | — | $101 | 4.4 |
| 36 Merrick Road | Rockville Centre 11570 | 2 | $68 | $68–$76 | $102 | 4.8 |
| 925 Spring Road | Pelham 10803 | 3 | $69 | $69–$69 | $103 | 4.8 |
| 3128 Northern Blvd | Long Island City 11101 | 4 | $70 | $70–$86 | $104 | 4.8 |
| 4116 Austin Blvd | Island Park 11558 | 1 | $71 | — | $107 | 4.8 |
| 385 Gerard Ave | Bronx 10451 | 4 | $71 | $71–$86 | $107 | 4.8 |
| 220-02 Jamaica Ave | Queens Village 11428 | 2 | $78 | $78–$78 | $118 | 4.7 |
| 285 Peninsula Blvd | Hempstead 11550 | 2 | $78 | $78–$96 | $116 | 4.8 |
| 137 Saw Mill River Road | Yonkers 10701 | 6 | $80 | $80–$94 | $120 | 4.8 |
| 484 Sunrise Hwy | Rockville Centre 11570 | 2 | $81 | $81–$82 | $121 | 4.7 |
| 2461 Knapp Street | Brooklyn 11235 | 4 | $81 | $81–$106 | $121 | 4.8 |
| 5002 2nd Ave | Brooklyn 11232 | 4 | $82 | $82–$106 | $122 | 4.8 |
| 1 Seaview Blvd | Port Washington 11050 | 2 | $87 | $87–$89 | $131 | 4.8 |
| 400 Nepperhan Ave | Yonkers 10701 | 1 | $90 | — | $134 | 4.7 |
| 4920 Van Dam St | Long Island City 11101 | 3 | $90 | $90–$108 | $134 | 4.7 |
| 2696 Fulton Street | Brooklyn 11207 | 2 | $93 | $93–$94 | $139 | 4.7 |
| 24-01 Brooklyn Queens Expy | Woodside 11377 | 1 | $94 | — | $142 | 4.8 |
| 955 Saw Mill River Road | Yonkers 10710 | 3 | $98 | $98–$107 | $146 | 4.8 |
| 1062 Saint Johns Pl | Brooklyn 11213 | 2 | $100 | $100–$117 | $150 | 4.8 |
| 1534 Utica Ave | Brooklyn 11234 | 1 | $101 | — | $151 | 4.7 |
| 91 Cuttermill Road | Great Neck 11021 | 2 | $102 | $102–$102 | $154 | 4.9 |
| 4102 Northern Blvd | Long Island City 11101 | 1 | $105 | — | $157 | 4.8 |
| 1250 Rockaway Ave | Brooklyn 11236 | 3 | $110 | $110–$130 | $164 | 4.7 |
| 875 Brush Ave | Bronx 10465 | 2 | $112 | $112–$117 | $168 | 4.9 |
| 269 Gold St | Brooklyn 11201 | 1 | $130 | — | $196 | 4.8 |
| 72 Emerson Place | Brooklyn 11205 | 4 | $134 | $134–$150 | $200 | 4.7 |
Ledgewood is 62% cheaper, 65 km away
| Market | Distance | Median 5x5 | vs Brooklyn |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jersey City, NJ | 11 km | $55 | -29% |
| Bethpage, NY | 39 km | $56 | -28% |
| Bridgewater, NJ | 54 km | $46 | -41% |
| Ledgewood, NJ | 65 km | $30 | -62% |
Where these numbers come from. 35 advertised prices read from Public
Storage's own published listings across 35 locations, last checked
2026-08-27.
Online rate vs regular rate. Every listing publishes two figures. Measured across thousands of observations, the regular rate is 1.5× the online rate at the median, with 88% inside 1% of that and none outside 1.40–1.60×. That is a pricing rule, not a second quote. The online rate is the promotional price for booking on the web; the regular rate is what the unit reverts to. Budget on the regular rate. Comparisons here hold the basis constant, so the gap between locations is real either way.
These are advertised rates for new rentals, not quotes — Public Storage states prices are not guaranteed and they move with availability. Insurance, admin fees and limited-time offers are not included.
How this is measured. The sampling, the percentile method and the rules for withholding a figure are set out on the methodology page. The figures are published as CC BY 4.0 and may be reused with attribution.
Cite this. Storage Price Index (2026). Public Storage 5x5 storage unit prices in Brooklyn, NY. Read 2026-08-27. CC BY 4.0. https://storagepriceindex.com/storage/brooklyn-ny/5x5/
Online rate vs regular rate. Every listing publishes two figures. Measured across thousands of observations, the regular rate is 1.5× the online rate at the median, with 88% inside 1% of that and none outside 1.40–1.60×. That is a pricing rule, not a second quote. The online rate is the promotional price for booking on the web; the regular rate is what the unit reverts to. Budget on the regular rate. Comparisons here hold the basis constant, so the gap between locations is real either way.
These are advertised rates for new rentals, not quotes — Public Storage states prices are not guaranteed and they move with availability. Insurance, admin fees and limited-time offers are not included.
How this is measured. The sampling, the percentile method and the rules for withholding a figure are set out on the methodology page. The figures are published as CC BY 4.0 and may be reused with attribution.
Cite this. Storage Price Index (2026). Public Storage 5x5 storage unit prices in Brooklyn, NY. Read 2026-08-27. CC BY 4.0. https://storagepriceindex.com/storage/brooklyn-ny/5x5/